A Psychological Rereading of Khaghani's Self-Praise: From Inferiority Complex to Defense Mechanisms

Document Type : Research article

Author

Professor of Persian Language and Literature, University of Kurdistan,r Sanandaj, Iran

Abstract

One of the important elements in the poetry of Khaqani Shervani (c.1126- 1200CE/520-595 AH) is his self-praise, which has provoked numerous critical reactions in recent decades and has led to incorrect judgments and comments about him. This research, based on the psychological theories of Alfred Adler (1870-1937) and Anna Freud (1895-1982), attempts to reinterpret Khaghani's self-praise in light of the two concepts of compensatory defense mechanisms and healthy narcissism, and uses a descriptive-analytical research method to answer these questions: First, what the nature of self-praise is in Khaqani's poetry and what components distinguish it from mere egotism; second, how these self-praises can be analyzed within the framework of the theory of healthy narcissism and the defense mechanism of compensation, and finally, what the relationship between Khaqani's self-praises and the discourse of power and the socio-cultural context of his era is. The findings show that Khaghani's self-praise stems from his real capabilities and his awareness of his scientific and artistic status, and on a psychological level, it is more of a healthy narcissism and a compensatory defense mechanism than a sign of pathological narcissism. In addition, there are signs of humility in his poems, which, along with the issue of love and Khaghani's romances, are aimed at rejecting incorrect judgments about him, because it seems that many previous studies have reached one-sided and incomplete analyses by failing to distinguish between healthy and pathological narcissism.

Highlights

The analysis of Khaqani's poems shows that Khaqani's self-praise stems from his real abilities, extensive knowledge, and unique skill in using his linguistic and literary abilities in composing poetry, rather than some kind of unsupported and exaggerated claim. From this perspective, this feature can be interpreted in light of the compensatory defense mechanism. At the social and historical level, these self-praises are also linked to the discourse of power; because in a competitive atmosphere and hierarchy of care, highlighting oneself is considered a legitimate means of gaining and maintaining cultural and literary status. Humility and love for family are also used to reject pathological narcissism. In sum, recognizing the distinction between healthy and harmful narcissism, paying attention to the historical and discursive contexts of poetry, and understanding the true progenitor of Khaqani's self-praises, provides the possibility of a multilayered, fair, and more scientific reading of Khaqani's personality and poetry, a reading that can lead to a redefinition of traditional judgments about this great poet.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Adler, A. (1927). Understanding Human Nature. New York: Greenberg.
Adler, A. (1938). Social Interest: A Challenge to Mankind. London: Faber and Faber.
Behnāmfar, Mohammad and Tāleʾi, Zeynab (2014) “Tahlil-e ravan-šenāxtiye xodsetāyi-hāye Xāqāni” (Psychological Analysisof Khaghaniʾs Self-Eulogies according to Karen Horney). Journal of Lyrical Literature researches, v. 12. Issue 22. Serial Number 22. pp. 69-92 [In Persian].
Blackman, Jerome S. (2013) 101 Mekanism-e defāʾi (101 Defense Mechanism) tr. by Qolāmrezā Javādzāde. Tehran: Arjomand Publications [In Persian].
Dašti, Ali (2002) Xāxāni, šāʾer-e dir-āšenā (Khaghani, a poet Recognized too Late). Tehran: Amirkabir Publications [In Persian].
Esteʾlāmi, Mohammad (2008) Naqd-o šarh-e qasāyed-e Xāxāni bar asās-e Taqrirāt-e Foruzānfar (Criticism and explanation of Khaghaniʾs poems based on the statements of Professor Foruzanfar). Tehran: Zavvār Publications [In Persian].
Freud, A. (1936). The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defence. London: Hograth Press.
Hassanzāde Niri, Mohammad Hasan & Rezā Jamšidi & Ruhollāh Heydari (2016) “Oqdeye heqārat yā oqdaye bartari” (Superiority or Inferiority Complex: Analysis of Khaghaniʾs Poetry Based on the Principles of Individual Psychology, Literary Text Research). v. 20. Issue 67. pp. 85-106. Doi: 10.22054/LTR.2016.3941. [In Persian].
Holmes, Jeremy (2019) Xodšiftegi (Narcissism). tr. Mahyār Alinaqi. Tehran: Bineš.
Kāfi, Qolāmrezā (1401) “Barrasi va tahlil-e gune-hāye faxr dar divān-e Xāqāni" (Study and Analysis of the Types of Pride in Khaqaniʾs Divan). Interpretation and Analysis of Persian Language and Literature Texts (Dehkhoda). v. 14. n. 53. pp. 17-41. [In Persian].
   Kazzāzi, Mir Jalāloddin (1989). Roxsār-e sobh (Morning’s Face). Tehran: Markaz Publications. [In Persian].
   Kazzāzi, Mir Jalāloddin (2002). Gozāreš-e došvari-hāye divān-e Xāqāni (Report on the Difficulties of the Khaghani’s Divan). Tehran: Markaz Publishing House. [in Persian].
Milanifar, Behruz (1995). Behdāšt-e Ravāni (Mental Health). Tehran: Qumes Publications. [In Persian].
Moʾayyed širazi, Jafar (1993). Šeʾr-e Xāqāni (Khghaniʾs poetry). Shiraz: Shiraz University Publications. [In Persian].
Nuri, Esmāʾil (2016) Taʾammol-i bar xodšiftegi va šenāxt-e šaxsiyat-e xodšifte (A reflection on narcissism and the recognition of the narcissistic personality). Tehran: Arjomand Publications. [In Persian].
Pārsā, Seyyed Ahmad (2006). “Stylistics of Xāqāniʾs Satires”, Shiraz Universityʾs Scientific-Research Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences. no. 48. pp. 57-67. [In Persian].
Rāstgu, Seyyed Mohammad (2013) “Parādoks-e takabbor va tavāzoʾ dar šeʾr va šaxsiyyat-e Xāqāni” (Arrogance-Modesty Paradox in Khaghani’s poetry and personality). Didactic Literature. v.5. pp. 47-78. [In Persian].

Sādeqi-maneš, Ali et al. (2023) “Barrasiye ravān-šenāxtiye ʾelal-e xod-setāyi dar šeʾr-e Xāqāni” (Psychological study of the causes of self-praise in Khaqaniʾs poetry based on the theories of Alfred Adler). v. 1. issue 2. serial 2. pp.57-76. [In Persian].

Saʾdi širazi, Mosleh al-Din (1989) Bustan-e Saʾdi (Saadiʾs Garden). Tehran: Xārazmi Publications. [In Persian].
Saʾdi širazi, Mosleh al-Din (1996) Kolliyyāt (Collected Verses). ed. Mohammad-Ali Foruqi. Tehran: Moʾiniyān Publications. [In Persian].
Šafiʾi Kadkani, Mohammad-Rezaā (2002) “Nokte-hāye now-yāfte dar divān-e Xāqāni” (Newly Discovered Facts in Khaghani’s Divan). Faculty of Literature and Humanities. University of Tabriz. v. 45. Issue 185. pp. 1-6. [In Persian].
Sandler, Joseph & Ethel Spector Persson & Peter Funagi (2023) Xod-šiftegi (Narcicism). tr. Zibā Tābān. Tehran: Negāh Publications [In Persian].
Širi, Qahramān (2012) Ebhām, faryād-e nātamām: goftemān-e ebhām dar farhang-e Iran (Ambiguity, Unfinished Cry: The Discourse of Ambiguity in Iranian Culture and Literature). Hamedan: Bu-Ali Sinā University Press. [In Persian].
Xāqāni šervani, Afzal al-Din (1978). Tohfat al-Eraqayn (The Gift of the Iraqis). Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications. [In Persian].
Xāqāni šervani, Afzal al-Din (1996). Divān, ed Mir Jalāloddin Kazzāzi. Tehran: Markaz Publication. [In Persian].
Xāqāni, Afzal al-Din Badil (1978) Divān. ed. Seyyed Ziyāʾaddinin Sajjādi. Tehran: Zavvār Publications. [In Persian].
Yahaqqi, Mohammad-Jaʾfar (1992) Tārix-e adabiyāt- e Irān (History of Iranian Literature).  Tehran: Company No. 2. pp. 57-76.
Zarinkub, Abdolhoseyn (1999) Didār bā Kaʾbeye jān (Meeting with the Kaʾba of Spirit). Tehran: Soxan Publishing House. [In Persian].
Zarinkub, Abdolhoseyn (2536). Bā karvān-e helleh (With the Caravan of Hillah). Tehran: Jāvidān Publishing House. [In Persian].

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 03 November 2026
  • Receive Date: 06 June 2026
  • Revise Date: 13 July 2026
  • Accept Date: 03 November 2026
  • Publish Date: 03 November 2026